Keeping bots out of your signup forms

Bots fill in newsletter and contact forms by the thousand. They leave you with subscribers called "Utve Yhjubk", confirmation emails sent to addresses nobody reads, and a sender reputation that sinks until your real newsletter lands in spam. Five layers stop almost all of it, and none of them asks your visitors to click on traffic lights.
Who does this? Whoever owns your website, together with the person who runs the newsletter. Many form tools have the first layers built in. A custom form takes a developer about a day.

Five layers

  1. An invisible puzzle. While the visitor types, their browser solves a small sum in the background and your server checks the answer. People notice nothing, and a bot sending thousands of signups pays for each one in computing time. ALTCHA is free, open source and sets no cookies. Friendly Captcha works the same way and is paid. Cloudflare Turnstile is free and also invisible, but it sends visitor data to Cloudflare, so name it in your privacy statement. Google reCAPTCHA and hCaptcha follow visitors across sites and sometimes show image puzzles, so skip those.
  2. A hidden trap field. Add one field that people can't see or reach. Bots fill in every field they find, so anything written in it marks a bot. Give it a name browsers don't autofill: Chrome fills in fields called "company" or "website", and a real signup would then be dropped.
  3. A minimum time. Note when the form appeared and reject anything sent within a second. Scripts that post straight to your server never open the form at all, so they fail this check too.
  4. Tell bots they succeeded. Show a blocked bot the same "Thanks for signing up" as everyone else and drop the signup quietly. An error message would tell whoever runs the bot what to fix.
  5. Limit and confirm. Allow about ten signups per hour from one internet connection, and turn on double opt-in in your newsletter tool, so nobody joins your list until they click the link in the confirmation email.
Plan for all five. Bots that run a real browser solve the puzzle like any visitor; the trap field and the minimum time catch those.

Keep an eye on it

Let your form log every blocked attempt with the reason, never with the email address. A monthly look tells you whether a new wave is getting through. Watch for subscribers with random letters for names, a jump in unconfirmed signups and a sudden rise in bounces. Remove junk that slipped through before your next send, because mailing it hurts your deliverability.

How we do it

Our newsletter form on moralfabric.org runs all five layers: ALTCHA, a hidden field, a one-second minimum, the fake thank-you, ten signups per hour per connection, and double opt-in in MailerLite. When we cleaned our list in September 2026, 628 of its 840 records turned out to be bots. The puzzle was already in place, so we added the trap field and the minimum time the same day.

Your variation

Record which form tool you use, which of the five layers it covers, and who looks at the blocked attempts each month.

See also

15 Nov 2026 by Ruben