Your newsletter is the one channel you own: no algorithm decides who sees it. It works best when the whole team sends from one list and labels people the same way. This pattern covers that structure and the house rules that keep it clean. We use and recommend MailerLite: affordable, simple, and it has groups, segments and automations. Brevo and Mailchimp do the same jobs. Check our nonprofit software discounts before you pay list price.
Who does this? Whoever holds your newsletter or communications role. Setup takes about two hours; the rules apply on every send.
One list, labelled people
Keep one audience for the whole organisation. Separate lists per programme create duplicates, break unsubscribes and make privacy requests hard to handle.
Labels describe people. Use four kinds, each with a prefix:
src:how someone came in:src:website,src:event,src:petition. Set once, never changed.aud:who they are to you:aud:donor,aud:volunteer,aud:partner. Someone can have several.region:only when it changes what you send them.event:attendance worth reaching again:event:summit-2026.
In MailerLite, labels are called groups; the source fits best in a custom field that the signup form fills. Never make a label like
sent-april-newsletter: the campaign report already records who got what. New labels go through whoever owns the list, so the system stays consistent.Segments are saved filters on labels and activity. Every send goes to a segment, even if that segment is "everyone subscribed".
Signups
- Put a signup form on your website with double opt-in: a confirmation mail that keeps the list clean and proves consent.
- Record where each signup came from, with a form per page or a hidden field that reads the link's UTM tags.
- Import only people who agreed to hear from you specifically. A partner's or an event's list doesn't count.
- Send one welcome mail that says what to expect and offers one next step.
- Unsubscribes are final. Never add someone back by hand.
What to measure
Open rates are unreliable: Apple Mail loads the tracking pixel for many readers automatically, whether they read the mail or not. Look at clicks, unsubscribes and spam complaints per send, and at new signups per month in your website analytics. Tag every link in the newsletter following Tracking links so the visits it produces show up there. If you use the Moral Fabric app, the Community page shows subscriber growth and churn over time, and how many subscribers also donate.
Once a year, mail the people who haven't clicked anything in twelve months to ask if they still want the newsletter, and remove those who don't respond. A smaller list that reads keeps you out of the spam folder.
Deliverability
Send from a subdomain such as news.yourorg.org and authenticate it. See Email authentication and Email deliverability: staying out of the spam folder.
Keep groups in step with your other tools
In the Moral Fabric app, Segments can keep a MailerLite group up to date with people from your donation and event tools, so a new donor lands in
aud:donor without anyone copying lists.What's mandatory regardless
Every mail says who it's from and has a working unsubscribe link. Keep proof of consent (double opt-in does this for you) and handle requests to see or delete data; our privacy requests page shows what each tool does.
Your variation
Record your tool, your label list, who approves new labels, your sending rhythm and your clean-up rule.